Hilton Head Island isn't just a destination; it's an experience—and a huge part of that experience is diving fork-first into its incredible seafood scene. From the moment you breathe in that salty Lowcountry air, you know you're in for a treat. Finding the best seafood restaurants Hilton Head has to offer isn't just about picking a spot; it's about discovering where the ocean's bounty truly shines, from dockside shacks to elegant waterfront dining.
Forget generic recommendations. We've pulled together the essential guide for anyone craving truly fresh, expertly prepared seafood on this beloved island.
Hilton Head Seafood Scene: At a Glance
- Diverse Options: From casual crab shacks to upscale culinary experiences, Hilton Head caters to every taste and budget.
- Freshness is Key: Many restaurants pride themselves on serving locally caught, often dock-to-table, seafood.
- Iconic Views: Expect breathtaking marsh, intracoastal, or oceanfront dining at many top spots.
- Lowcountry Flavors: Don't miss out on regional specialties like shrimp and grits, deviled crab, and lowcountry boils.
- Customer Favorites: Look for oysters on the half shell, crab cakes, blackened fish, and inventive seafood preparations.
- Plan Ahead: Popular spots, especially those with water views, often require reservations or come with a wait.
Your Guide to Hilton Head's Unforgettable Seafood Experiences
Hilton Head Island is a culinary treasure chest, particularly for seafood lovers. The sheer variety ensures that whether you're looking for a romantic sunset dinner, a lively family meal, or a quick, delicious bite, you'll find it here. The island's culinary philosophy leans heavily into fresh, local ingredients, transforming the day's catch into memorable dishes that embody the spirit of the Lowcountry.
The Icons: Unmissable Seafood Mainstays
Some restaurants aren't just places to eat; they're institutions. These Hilton Head classics consistently deliver outstanding seafood, often paired with views that etch themselves into your memory.
Hudson's Seafood House On The Docks
Address: 1 Hudson Rd, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.6 Superb from 810 Reviews
Step into a piece of Hilton Head history at Hudson's, where fresh seafood has been a tradition for decades. Located on the historic Port Royal Sound, this restaurant is known for its commitment to serving seafood caught daily by its own fleet. The atmosphere is bustling and authentic, with a genuine dockside feel that's hard to replicate. You'll likely encounter a wait, but it's a testament to their enduring popularity and worth every minute.
Must-Try Dishes: Don't leave without trying their Raw Oysters on the Half Shell, a true taste of the local waters. The Fish and Chips (fried red snapper) offers a perfectly crispy exterior and flaky interior, while the Low Country Boil is a quintessential regional experience. For dessert, the Bessie's Peanut Butter Pie is a fan favorite.
Skull Creek Boathouse & Skull Creek Dockside
Boathouse Address: 397 Squire Pope Rd, Hilton Head Island (Rating: 4.5 Superb from 862 Reviews)
Dockside Address: 2 Hudson Rd, Hilton Head Island (Rating: 4.3 Superb from 551 Reviews)
These sister restaurants offer distinct but equally appealing experiences, both boasting spectacular waterfront views of the Lowcountry marshland—perfect for sunset dining. The Boathouse is known for its lively, energetic vibe and creative seafood dishes, along with refreshing drinks. Dockside focuses on fresh catches daily, with a slightly more relaxed, expansive atmosphere.
Boathouse Highlights: The Pecan Ginger Crusted Mahi Mahi is a standout, offering a unique flavor profile. Their Fried Shrimp with Cocktail Sauce is a classic done right, and the Chilled Seafood Platter is perfect for sharing.
Dockside Highlights: Highly recommended are the She-Crab Soup, rich and creamy, and their flavorful Crab Cakes. Their Fresh Oysters on the Half Shell are always a hit, and for a hearty meal, consider the Steamed Snow Crab Legs.
Quarterdeck
Address: 160 Lighthouse Rd, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.6 Superb from 603 Reviews
Nestled at the base of the iconic Harbour Town Lighthouse, Quarterdeck offers a sophisticated yet relaxed dining experience with unparalleled views of the marina. It’s a quintessential Hilton Head spot for a memorable meal, combining a fantastic location with a menu full of fresh, elevated seafood.
Customer Favorites: Indulge in their Fresh Maine Lobster for a truly special treat. The East Coast Shrimp and Grits offers a delightful twist on a Southern classic, and their Fried Calamari with Artichokes is a flavorful appetizer. Don't forget their signature desserts like Not Your Grandma's Key Lime Cheesecake.
Beachfront Bliss & Coastal Charm
For those dreaming of sand between their toes and the sound of waves complementing their meal, these restaurants offer the ultimate beachfront or coastal dining experience.
Coast
Address: 87 N Sea Pines Dr, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.6 Superb from 322 Reviews
Located right on the beach within the Sea Pines Beach Club, Coast delivers on its name with ample indoor and outdoor seating that practically spills onto the sand. It’s an ideal spot to enjoy a meal, listen to evening music, and even take a post-dinner stroll along the shore.
Signature Dishes: The Coast Signature Lobster Roll is a highlight, packed with sweet lobster meat. Their Cashew Crusted Atlantic Salmon offers a delicious crunch, and the Blue Crab and Corn Bisque is a comforting, creamy delight. For a fun start, try the Blackened Shrimp Nachos.
Sea Pines Beach Club
Address: 87 N Sea Pines Dr, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.6 Superb from 125 Reviews
A truly family-friendly destination, the Sea Pines Beach Club is a hub of activity with multiple dining options, including Coast. It’s praised for its good food, beautiful views, and the convenience of being able to spend the day at the beach and grab a delicious bite without leaving the property. Many guests find themselves returning multiple times.
Highlights: The Roasted Loaded Maine Lobster Mac and Cheese is an indulgent crowd-pleaser. For lighter fare, the Fish Tacos (with coleslaw) are fresh and flavorful, and their Kung Pao Fried Oysters offer a spicy, unexpected kick. You can also find Explore Hilton Head Oyster Bars at Coast and other spots within the club.
The Salty Dog Cafe
Address: 232 S Sea Pines Dr, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4 Good from 523 Reviews
An iconic and beloved Hilton Head institution, The Salty Dog Cafe is famous for its colorful apparel and casual, lively atmosphere in South Beach. It's a fun, family-friendly spot that serves up outstanding food, making it a must-visit for many island guests.
Customer Favorites: Their Lobster Grilled Cheese is a surprisingly decadent treat. The Calibogue Shrimp Salad is light and refreshing, and the Jake's Lowcountry Boil is a hearty, classic choice. Don't forget to grab some Jake's Hushpuppies!
Hidden Gems & Local Favorites
Sometimes the best discoveries are off the beaten path or come recommended by those who know the island best. These spots offer unique flavors and experiences cherished by locals and visitors alike.
The Sea Shack
Address: 6 Executive Park Rd, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.6 Superb from 324 Reviews
Don't let the unassuming exterior fool you; The Sea Shack is a beloved local secret (though its reputation is growing!). It's famous for its no-frills approach to incredibly fresh, perfectly fried, and grilled seafood. Expect a casual, cozy atmosphere and some of the best down-home cooking on the island.
Must-Try Dishes: The Popcorn Shrimp Platter is a hit, and their Sweet Potato Cornbread is legendary. Adventurous eaters will appreciate the Conch Fritters, and their classic Fish and Chips are always a solid choice. The She Crab Soup here is a rich, satisfying option.
Kenny B's French Quarter Cafe
Address: 70 Pope Ave, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.6 Superb from 334 Reviews
Bringing a taste of New Orleans to Hilton Head, Kenny B's is an amazing gem that offers a unique Cajun twist on seafood. The vibrant "Bulldog's decor" adds to the lively and friendly atmosphere, making it a fantastic spot for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.
Customer Favorites: Dive into a Fried Shrimp Basket with Corn and Hushpuppies for a Southern comfort meal. The Crawfish Etouffee is rich and authentic, and their Shrimp and Grits boast a flavorful Cajun kick. Don't miss the Fried Green Tomatoes.
Benny's Coastal Kitchen
Address: 75 SHRIMPERS ROW, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.6 Superb from 229 Reviews
Benny's Coastal Kitchen stands out for its diverse and creative seafood choices, elevating classic dishes with innovative flair. This spot offers a more refined culinary experience, perfect for those looking to explore seafood beyond the traditional fried platters.
Signature Dishes: The Crab Cake Napoleon with Fried Green Tomato and Creamy Gremolata is an absolute must-try, showcasing incredible flavors and textures. Their Brazilian Seafood Stew is a rich, hearty option, and the Shell Oysters - Du Jour are always a fresh delight. They also offer excellent Grouper and Seafood Cannelloni.
Fishcamp on Broad Creek
Address: 11 Simmons Rd, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.4 Superb from 476 Reviews
With a relaxed, dockside ambiance, Fishcamp on Broad Creek delivers classic Lowcountry fare with a focus on fresh, local ingredients. It's a favorite for both casual meals and enjoying the scenic views.
Customer Favorites: The Royal Tower Shellfish Tower is an impressive display of seafood bounty. Their Daufuskie Island Blue Crab Cakes are consistently praised, and the Low Country Boil is a fantastic communal meal. You can't go wrong with their Peel and Eat Shrimp or Parmesan-Crusted Grouper.
For the Oyster Aficionado
If the briny kiss of a fresh oyster is your idea of heaven, Hilton Head has several spots that specialize in these oceanic gems. From raw bars to Rockefeller-style, you'll find your oyster fix.
Old Oyster Factory Restaurant
Address: 101 Marshland Rd, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.3 Superb from 462 Reviews
As its name suggests, the Old Oyster Factory excels in all things oyster. Housed in a beautifully restored factory building with marsh views, it offers a refined dining experience focusing on quality seafood, particularly its namesake. The oysters here are consistently highly praised for their freshness and flavor.
Oyster Highlights: Of course, the Raw Oysters on the Half Shell are paramount. For cooked options, the Oysters Rockefeller are a rich, savory choice. Beyond oysters, their Lowcountry Blue Crab Cakes and Broad Creek Seafood Pasta are also popular. Complimentary hush puppies are a nice touch! When you're ready to Explore Hilton Head Oyster Bars, this is a top contender.
Other Notable Oyster Spots:
Many other restaurants on the island feature excellent oyster selections, including:
- Hudson's Seafood House On The Docks: Renowned for their raw oysters.
- Coast: Features a daily oyster selection.
- Sea Pines Beach Club: Offers oysters on the half shell and unique preparations like Kung Pao Fried Oysters.
- Skull Creek Boathouse/Dockside: Both offer fresh oysters on the half shell.
- Benny's Coastal Kitchen: Features "Shell Oysters - Du Jour."
Craving Crab? A Guide to Crab Leg & Cake Havens
Whether you're cracking into succulent crab legs or savoring a perfectly seasoned crab cake, Hilton Head has you covered.
The Crazy Crab (Jarvis Creek & Harbour Town)
Jarvis Creek Address: 104 William Hilton Pkwy, Hilton Head Island (Rating: 4.4 Superb from 670 Reviews)
Harbour Town Address: 149 Lighthouse Rd, Hilton Head Island (Rating: 4.4 Superb from 526 Reviews)
With two popular locations, The Crazy Crab is a go-to for hearty crab dishes and classic steamed seafood pots. Both locations offer a lively, family-friendly atmosphere, perfect for digging into a pile of seafood. If you're looking for Hilton Head crab leg restaurants, this spot is a top recommendation.
Crazy Crab Must-Haves: Their 1 2 lb Snow Crab Legs are a staple. The Captain Steamed Seafood Pot offers a generous mix of shrimp, crab, and other delights. For those who prefer fried, the Fried Scallops & Fried Shrimp App is a great starter, and the Broiled Seafood Platter is a comprehensive choice.
Carolina Crab Co
Address: 86 Helmsman Way, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.5 Superb from 242 Reviews
Carolina Crab Co is another excellent choice for crab enthusiasts, particularly for its highly praised crab cakes. This spot offers a relaxed dockside setting and a menu packed with Lowcountry favorites.
Customer Favorites: Their The Carolina Crab Cakes come highly recommended, even earning the "Marylander approved" stamp of excellence. The Lowcountry Shrimp Boil and JJ's Crab Lover's Boil are perfect for sharing. Don't overlook their fantastic Hush Puppies and Fried Grouper or Blackened Shrimp Tacos.
FISH Casual Coastal Seafood
Address: 1 N Forest Beach Dr, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.1 Good from 290 Reviews
For those with a serious appetite for crab, FISH Casual Coastal Seafood offers a tempting All You Can Eat Crab Legs option. It’s a straightforward, casual spot where the focus is firmly on generous portions of seafood.
Crab-Centric Choices: Beyond the AYCE crab legs, they also feature a Lowcountry Boil and a variety of other fresh seafood preparations, including Blackened Snapper and Steamed Oysters.
Upscale & Romantic: Seafood for Special Occasions
When you're looking for an elegant evening, impeccable service, and culinary artistry, these Hilton Head establishments deliver a sophisticated seafood dining experience.
Charlie's L'etoile Verte
Address: 8 New Orleans Rd, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.7 Superb from 1204 Reviews
Widely regarded for its five-star dining and service, Charlie's L'etoile Verte offers a sophisticated French-inspired menu with a strong emphasis on fresh, local seafood. It's the perfect place for an anniversary, special celebration, or simply to indulge in world-class cuisine.
Exceptional Seafood: The Atlantic Cod Encrusted in Parmesan Crust is a delicate and flavorful dish. Their Local Flounder Sauteed Meuniere is prepared to perfection, and the Blackened Red Fish showcases a bold, spicy flavor. Beyond seafood, their Ribeye with Fingerling Potatoes is also superb.
Red Fish Restaurant
Address: Red Fish Building, 8 Archer Rd, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.3 Superb from 715 Reviews
Red Fish offers a cozy, intimate, and romantic atmosphere, making it ideal for special occasions. With an impressive wine cellar and a commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients, you can expect delicious, creative meals and attentive service.
Culinary Highlights: The Red Fish Classic Scallops w Lobster & Shrimp Mac & Cheese is an indulgent, must-try dish. The Firecracker Calamari is a popular appetizer, and the Blackened Grouper is consistently praised for its flavor and preparation.
Alexander's Restaurant & Wine Bar
Address: 76 Queens Folly Rd, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.1 Good from 797 Reviews
This lovely restaurant boasts an excellent menu and impeccable service, often accompanied by a coveted view of a man-made lagoon/lazy river. Alexander's is known for its elegant ambiance and offers an early dining menu (smaller portions) off-season, making fine dining accessible.
Menu Standouts: Their Broiled Lobster Tail is a luxurious choice. The Oysters Alexander's offer a unique take on a classic, and the Blackened Grouper is a reliable favorite. Pair your meal with a selection from their extensive wine list.
Catch 22 Restaurant
Address: 37 New Orleans Rd, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.5 Superb from 192 Reviews
Catch 22 is an intimate dining experience focusing on fresh seafood and prime cuts. Known for its sophisticated menu and cozy setting, it’s a wonderful choice for a romantic dinner or a quiet, high-quality meal.
Seafood Specialties: The Garlic Basil Broiled Maine Lobster Tail is a showstopper. The Pan Seared Sea Scallops are perfectly cooked and flavorful, and the unique Saffron Wreck Fish and Oysters offers an adventurous palate. Don't skip the Peanut Butter Sushi for a memorable dessert.
ELA'S On the Water
Address: 1 Shelter Cove Ln, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4 Good from 1188 Reviews
ELA'S On the Water provides a beautiful dining experience with amazing food and generous portion sizes. The kind and hospitable staff further enhance the elegant atmosphere, which often includes stunning water views.
Top Choices: The Steamed Lobster with Lobster Risotto is a rich and satisfying meal. Their Pan Seared Diver Scallops are consistently praised for their tenderness, and the Blackened Yellowfin Tuna offers a robust flavor. The Ela's Crab Stack is a popular appetizer.
Sea Grass Grille
Address: 807 William Hilton Pkwy #1000, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.4 Superb from 138 Reviews
Sea Grass Grille is a charming spot where the owner and staff are noted for exceeding expectations. It offers a refined menu focusing on fresh, expertly prepared seafood in an inviting setting.
Highlights: The Grilled Salmon with Citrus Tarragon Beurre Blanc is a popular choice, light and flavorful. The Mahi Mahi Watermelon Salad offers a refreshing combination, and the Sauteed Flounder is a classic preparation done right.
Casual Bites & Unique Twists
Sometimes you just want something delicious without the fuss, or perhaps a unique take on seafood. These spots offer great food in a more relaxed setting, or with a distinctive culinary approach.
Slapfish
Address: 1024 William Hilton Pkwy, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.3 Superb from 174 Reviews
Despite being a counter-service establishment, Slapfish delivers amazing food that transcends typical "fast food." It's a fresh, modern take on seafood, offering creative dishes in a casual environment.
Unique Offerings: The Lobster Grilled Cheese and Fries is a decadent and popular choice. Their Fish Taco Grilled and Fried Fish Taco are fresh and flavorful, and the New England Clam Chowder is a comforting classic. The Shrimp Ceviche is a light and vibrant option.
Up the Creek Pub & Grill
Address: 18 Simmons Rd, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 4.4 Superb from 181 Reviews
Offering an amazing dining experience with very nice staff, Up the Creek Pub & Grill is a fantastic alternative to traditional fast food. It provides a relaxed pub atmosphere with surprisingly good seafood options.
Casual Seafood Picks: The Trigger Fish Sandwich is a local favorite, offering a unique fish choice. Their Fried Flounder Basket is a reliable, crispy option, and don't forget their Homemade Hushpuppies.
DryDock Seafood & Spirits
Address: 840 William Hilton Pkwy, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 3.7 Good from 110 Reviews
Popular with both locals and visitors, DryDock Seafood & Spirits is a great spot for watching sports while enjoying good food. It’s a straightforward, friendly place for a casual meal.
Go-To Dishes: The Fried Shrimp Basket w Tater Tots is a classic choice. Their Fish and Chips are also a solid option, and the Spicy Shrimp offers a kick.
The Lobster Bar
Address: 81 Pope Ave unit 201, Hilton Head Island
Rating: 3.7 Good from 142 Reviews
For fantastic food and service in a casual setting, The Lobster Bar is a solid choice, particularly if you're craving lobster rolls. It brings a taste of New England to the Lowcountry.
Lobster Roll Perfection: The Fresh Connecticut Lobster Roll and Crab and Lobster Roll with Chips are the stars of the show here, packed with fresh, delicious seafood. Their Fried Calamari and Fish and Chips are also popular.
Beyond the Plate: Choosing Your Perfect Hilton Head Seafood Spot
With so many excellent options, how do you narrow down the best seafood restaurants Hilton Head has for you? Consider these factors to ensure your culinary adventure is exactly what you're looking for.
Consider the Vibe
- Casual & Lively: Are you looking for a bustling, family-friendly atmosphere where you can relax and be a bit messy cracking crab legs? Think The Crazy Crab, Hudson's, or The Salty Dog.
- Upscale & Romantic: Planning a special night out? Charlie's L'etoile Verte, Red Fish, Alexander's, and ELA'S offer refined ambiance and exquisite cuisine.
- Laid-back Local: For a true taste of local life without the frills, The Sea Shack or Up the Creek Pub & Grill might be your speed.
Location, Location, Location
- Oceanfront/Beach Access: Coast, Sea Pines Beach Club, or The Salty Dog offer direct beach proximity.
- Marsh/Intracoastal Views: Skull Creek Boathouse/Dockside, Old Oyster Factory, and Fishcamp on Broad Creek provide stunning Lowcountry marsh panoramas, often with spectacular sunsets.
- Harbour Town Charm: Quarterdeck and The Crazy Crab (Harbour Town) put you right in the heart of the iconic lighthouse village.
What's Fresh Today?
Many of Hilton Head's best restaurants pride themselves on serving local, seasonal catches. Don't hesitate to ask your server about the fresh fish of the day, or look for specials that highlight what just came off the boat. This is your chance to Taste Hilton Heads Fresh Seafood at its peak.
Check the Menu
While our "customer favorites" give you a great starting point, glance at the full menu online if possible. Look for specific dishes or preparations that appeal to you. Do they offer steamed, fried, grilled, or blackened options? Are there Lowcountry specialties you want to try, or are you hoping for more inventive culinary creations?
Reservations vs. Walk-ins
Especially during peak season or for popular spots with prime views, reservations are highly recommended. Restaurants like Hudson's and Skull Creek often have a wait, but many offer pleasant waiting areas (sometimes with a bar or live music). For more casual spots, walk-ins are usually fine, but it's always wise to check ahead.
Your Hilton Head Seafood Adventure Awaits!
Hilton Head Island truly is a paradise for seafood lovers. With an abundance of fresh catches, talented chefs, and diverse dining atmospheres, you're guaranteed to find a meal that satisfies your cravings and creates lasting memories. From the iconic institutions serving classic Lowcountry boils to the upscale establishments pushing culinary boundaries, each restaurant offers a unique slice of the island's vibrant food scene. So, embark on your delicious journey, explore these incredible establishments, and let the fresh ocean flavors of Hilton Head captivate your palate. Enjoy!